Gaslighting discussion (split from: Justin’s Miscellaneous Posts)

[anonymous33]

@JustinCEO

@anonymous33

I think you might specifically be talking about the ideas from this post .

ya that

You said:

@JustinCEO

cuz with TCS Coercion you can coerce someone totally by accident while doing something innocuous

But the thing you are actually talking about is not an idea from TCS Philosophy. The actual post that you are talking about said:

@formerTCSer

But this is the kind of thing I think TCS ignored.

It is problematic to bring up this new idea about what TCS Coercion is, and just talk about it as if it were the standard view of TCS Coercion, without actually referencing anything or explaining it at all.

I think the idea might actually be formerTCSer’s original idea. I’m not sure. I don’t recall seeing it written down anywhere else though.

I agree with what formerTCSer said. I think their ideas about coercion are correct. And I still think that the analogy between gaslighting and TCS Coercion lines up well. You seem to think it does not, but you have not clearly stated your idea of what the disagreement is.

I can try to guess your disagreement and reply to that. But that involves things like responding to what your words imply instead of responding to things you have clearly stated. And you have previously responded negatively when I did that.