Replying to "Errors Merit Post-Mortems"[Dface]

At 1:43, Hydramist says this:

He gets a rapid fire. I get it off. It’s lucky. We get the fear. It’s a good fear. And we go for the mine blast.

At first glance, I’m wondering what this has to do with a postmortem. I don’t know it’s part of one or not.

I notice a lot of times that people who review their gameplay and mistakes do a kind of commentary about it. It sounds like a play by play of stuff that happens. There doesn’t seem to be anything too wrong going on in the quote.

I have some idea about each ability or attack or item being used. Like, sometimes I see an attack happen or a debuff is applied.

Saying it’s a “good fear” sounds like a good play or getting lucky with it.

Here’s the next part a few seconds later:

I go for the defensive penants here cuz I wasn’t topped and I was like, well, I just want to make sure I’m staying safe.

I looked online what a “penant” is and found that it’s actually penance. It’s an ability for the class/race I think Hydramist is playing.

I think he’s stating one of his goals in the quote. So if there’s a mistake that happens then it could be with one of the goals that were stated. He could be playing too safe or not safe enough and that’s something he could rewind and watch for.

I think he already mentioned his strategy and a goal. If there’s something wrong he can watch his replay and analyze if he could do better. He could see that maybe the mortar wouldn’t be enough to kill the cat or that he was going to compromise his safety if he did a certain action.

It’s kind of hard so far to see the postmortem in the video. I think I probably need to think about what you do in one and relate it to the video…Idk. I know you investigate an error in a postmortem. I think he does that some for the first duel. He investigates stuff.

He’s reviewing what happened to understand how the match went. That is part of a post mortem even though that part isn’t focused on mistakes. Understanding what happened in the match is a step towards finding mistakes.

Yeah him reviewing what happened is him going over the play by play of the duel…I think. Idk what reviewing means. What happened tho is the duel(s). They were using abilities/items/other things to fight. He’s reviewing that stuff.

Also, the duels already happened. They didn’t happen at the time he was watching the footage. The footage helps to see what happened. He can look at the footage to review what happened.

Here’s a merriam webster definition of review:

an act or process of carefully looking at or examining the quality, condition, etc., of something or someone

I can’t tell if Hydramist is examining stuff carefully. I think he’s carefully looking at what happened cuz he’s describing the details moment to moment. Like, he says that the enemy gets a rapid fire and he(Hydramist) gets it off . He also says that it’s lucky. That sounds to me like he’s being careful. Not too sure.

Reviewing just sounds like you’re looking at something again. Like, you talk about what happened. You’re not focused on playing so you have more attention describe what happened.

What does understanding how the match went means? Like, what was good and what was bad? Is he trying to understand what were the exact events? Or maybe have a good idea about what happened?

When people talk about how like how work went or an event, they’re asking sometimes if it was good or bad or boring or nothing good happened. If that’s related to Hydramist’s duels then I think it’s his good plays and his bad ones.

Another interpretation of the quote I have is that he’s literally looking over what happened to get an idea of what happened. If he understands how the match went then he could see what he did good or bad or if he made a mistake.

I think I understand this more than when I initially read it this morning. I think if you know the context or what happened then you could find an error. If you find an error then you could postmortem it. I think it helps too with knowing how the error happened.

When I’ve done postmortems on my own time it helped to provide the context. It’s hard to describe in words why but I think you can be more specific about an error.

Let’s say you work in a fast food restaurant and you have two orders, and both of them you made the wrong drink. If you find out one order had 4 combos in it and the other was just with some fries then wouldn’t that change things? On one of the orders it sounds like you probably dont know how to keep up with making many drinks. The other error sounds like you’re maybe inexperienced.

It’s not focused on mistakes. I think I remember something on one of postmortem articles about finding errors. Like, you may not even have an error to investigate yet but that doesn’t mean what you’re doing isn’t part of the postmortem. I dont remember exactly where

Why is it a step towards finding mistakes? Idk but it’s like it helps with finding mistakes. If you know what happened then you can find when you messed up. You can say what you did fine and where you messed up.

It’s hard to see how understanding is a step towards finding mistakes. Im thinking if you know what happened then stuff becomes more clear and you find what’s an error.

I think I see how this quote is part of a postmortem. Hydramist has been playing the game it seems for a bit and knows how stuff works. He knows when an ability or attack or item goes off and he knows who’s getting damaged and who won. He already knows some about the match cuz he’s played it, but if someone else with similar experience observed the gameplay, they can understand how the match went too.

Let’s say Hydramist is observing what happened but stuff is different. If Hydramist didn’t get the “rapid fire” off then you could find a mistake there. If it wasn’t based on luck then that could be a skill issue thing. Maybe it’s the thing that lead to his death in the duel. I’m assuming here rapid fire is like a debuff. I don’t know for sure what that is.

Another example of understanding what happened to find mistakes: Let’s say Hydramist gets the fear, but it wasn’t a good fear. Hydramist could understand that he got like a debuff going but it wasn’t good. That’s a problem. It could probably not be good cuz the timing was bad or that the target was too far away. I think you could find a mistake here. Again, I don’t know what makes a good fear.

A part of me is thinking that you could find mistakes in a bad way. Like, everything could seem like a mistake, and you’re not focusing on the right one. Idk how you find mistakes well. It sounds obvious to do in a way but also like you could overthink it.

These are examples of trying to understanding what happened to find mistakes. I think Hydramist already kind of knew he used defensive penance at some points in the match, but I think he knows now that he used it after a small exchange of abilites/skills/items. I’m not too sure about this.

In a way we the viewers are understanding what happened. If they’re new like me, you could learn a bit why Hydramist is doing what he’s doing. Like, we now know that Hydramist activated the ability cuz he wasn’t topped off(I think that means we wasn’t at full health). He also gives an account of what he thought when setting off the ability. He wanted to make sure he was staying safe. That’s something that happened. That also relates to a goal and I think to finding mistakes.

I don’t have much knowledge about the game but it seems like Hydramist’s intention of trying to stay safe is going ok. Idk if that contributes to making a mistake or if he was being too safe cuz of that. I think we can probably find a mistake somewhere related to knowing that he was trying to stay safe.

Also, I don’t know if he was trying stay safe in just that part of the encounter or the whole encounter. Maybe he’s being aggressive at times instead of staying safe. Idk

I don’t think I know a whole lot about how understanding what happened is a step towards finding mistakes. What that makes me think of is how some ideas pass at some goals and how some don’t with other goals. Like, the idea of using a spoon for eating soup is a good idea and goal. But if you use a chopstick for eating soup then it sounds like a bad idea for the goal.

I think if you didn’t know what happened then you wouldn’t know how the mistake happened. You don’t know if someone used a spoon or a chopstick for the goal of eating soup. You just hear that they succeeded or failed.

I think learning what happened is like finding out that you did have the idea of using a spoon to eat soup but you were out of spoons that day. That lead to you failing at eating the soup. Is this similar to understanding what happened to find mistakes? You find that the mistake is that you ran out of utensils or didn’t try a different utensil or method.

At 1:56 Hydramist says this(per transcript):

And then we get the double dots on the cats reshield.

This is more of what happened. I think if learned what a “double dots” is and a “cats reshield” is then I could understand what happened. Those are video game terms Im familiar with. Also, if I do understand what happened then maybe I can find Hydramist’s mistakes too?

“double dots” sounds like two dots at once. Dots stand for damage over time I think so that could be a debuff that hurts you over time. That sounds like it could be based on luck or skill. Would knowing if it’s luck or skill help with finding mistakes?

For “cats reshield”, the transcription messed up. I think Hydramist actually said, “And then we get the double dot on the cat. Reshield.” Like i think he prob reshielded after getting the dots off on the cat. Reshield sounds like if you had a shield health bar and you regenerate it. It also sounds like u protect yourself with physical shield.

I was thinking that it kind of makes sense to understand what happened to know how the match went. Like, we have automatizations which allow us to do things without much conscious attention. I don’t think we’d know every little thing we did. That stuff was done automatically to focus on other stuff. You would prob have to look at a video recording to know how stuff went down exactly.

I was able to see the dots happening when I watched the video again. There were two different numbers of damage happening over time. They were close together and the cat received a lot of damage.

I don’t really see the reshield happening but I see like an aura around Hydramist when he said reshield. It was like a glowing aura. That sounds like a buff.

Im kind of understanding what’s happening to see how the match went. It looks like he could’ve done heavy enough damage to kill the cat but the cat survives. My first questions would be why did you do so much damage to the cat and use so many resources? Will it take a part later in the fight? Were you not doing enough damage to kill it? Why weren’t you able to kill it?

From 2:00-2:16, Hydramist says this:

Should have been pushing up this way a bit more really. But now he because of where I’m standing, he can push on me. I don’t have fear available yet. And the cat is like 30% or something.

The first sentence sounds different than just trying to understand what happened. He’s suggesting a different play. Is that part of the postmortem? What it sounds like is that there’s a potential error and that there’s a different way to go about things.

Did Hydramist find a mistake at the time of the first sentence? In a way, he is figuring out what happened cuz instead of going/moving to where he suggests, he observed that he went a different way. It’s the original way of the video.

But now he because of where I’m standing, he can push on me.

This sounds interesting. It’s like he made a mistake but did it cost him the match? Could it have cost him a match? The mistake seems to be his positioning. Why was it a mistake? What lead to the goal failing? What is the goal? I think the goal is to avoid getting pushed by the opponent. The mistake was his positioning; that led to the goal failing I think. Can you postmortem that? It didn’t seem to cost him the match. What did it cost him?

The dots (shadow word pain, devouring plague) and the power word shield are priest spells.

As broader context, most spells in WoW trigger a 1.5 second global/shared cooldown, giving wow a tempo where you’re often doing one spell every 1.5 seconds and choosing which one to do and what order to do things.

Ok, I think I saw those dots as debuffs on the cat’s health bar. For the power word shield, I see a lot of abilities/spells on the right side of the screen. Maybe he clicked on one of those for the effect. I think he’s playing a priest class to use the spell.

I was seeing like a timer or refreshing effect on most of the spells/abilities on the screen. Im thinking that’s probably from the global cooldown.

I also think then that when Hydramist used power word shield, it was part of wow’s spell tempo. He was choosing which spells to do and what order to do things. The order for the section of gameplay would be dots then shield.

For Hydramist’s first sentence, why should he have been pushing? What way should he have pushed? How much should he have pushed? When he says “pushing up this way a bit more really.”, what does “really” mean? Actually? Is that the better play? Is he sure about it?

I do notice that people who review their gameplay talk about what they should be doing. I’m kinda unsure if that’s part of the postmortem. I wonder if they actually should be doing something or not. Why didn’t they know at the time of recording? Why after the recording? It sounds like they’re not actually fixing the mistake.

Sometimes, when I review my gameplay it’s hard to tell what I should be doing. When I do say what to do, it’s a little hard to know if I’m right or not. It becomes kind of hard to review gameplay and fix mistakes. It’s like I have a general understanding of what’s happening and what I should do, but it’s not good enough to help w/ improving.

I think Hydramist is able to identify something about him and his opponent. It’s like he’s able to read well what happened. Because he acted in one way, it lead to an opening and to him getting pushed. That seems like part of a postmortem cuz you’re understanding more about what happened.

It’s a lot like pros analyzing chess games, they can read what’s currently happening on the board. They can tell if someone made a blunder or what a good move looks like. They can tell if x and y happens then one of the players gain an advantage or disadvantage. That stuff sounds like it’s part of a postmortem but not sure. It makes me think that they’re identifying goals and errors.

I don’t have fear available yet. And the cat is like 30% or something.

The two sentences are good to know. It makes sense that an ability or spell would have a cooldown and he’s not able to use it. Also, it makes sense to keep track of the cat’s health if the goal was to kill the cat to kill the hunter. If you were expecting to kill the cat earlier, what went wrong? That literally sounds like an error.

Not having fear available sounds like being at a disadvantage. That probably could help with dealing getting pushed on by the enemy. Idk what that spell/ability does.