I see. That wasn’t exactly my intention, although I did think that to some extent. It’s obvious to me that access to ID can be manipulated to discriminate against some voters/citizens, but I underestimated the extent to which it can/does happen. I am probably biased also by how easy it is sometimes in other countries, and forgetting that a lot of this is state managed in the US.
In some other countries there are also laws making it illegal not to be registered to vote. The advantage of those laws is that the govt is somewhat obliged to go out of their way to make it accessible.
There was a Mexican Repatriation that happened in the US in 1930s. According to Wikipedia, between 300,000 - 2,000,000 people repatriated or were deported, and 40-60% of those people were US citizens. Some people are worried that this current push will also end up deporting citizens, since there are US citizens who are not easily able to prove their citizenship.
I had no idea. The concerns seem a lot more valid now.
It seems like (today with all the ICE stuff) there’s a good opportunity to help those citizens since there’s now a point of government contact and the current administration could point to procedures that solve the problem for US citizens. (But I haven’t heard about something like this)
The govt could also proactively advertise to those people and run special programs or whatever. (This might be expensive but it’s a problem that needs to be solved at some point)
I’m not sure if you have a specific point about the Democratic presidents not solving the issue. There are lots of issues they haven’t solved. One of the issues is that both parties spend a lot of time fighting each other. A lot of people on the left are pretty disillusioned with the democrats, and a lot of people actually argue that the democrat vs republican dichotomy is flawed, because neither one is actually on the side of the people.
My (implicit) point was that when parties complain about something, and are then in power but don’t solve it, then that’s an indication of dishonesty, incompetence, or that an issue isn’t really that bad. I can see how the US federal-state dynamic makes it much more complex though (which I didn’t really consider before).