I think the biggest problem with your prompt was that you cut out all context. IME it’s fine to quote a specific thing from a body of text provided that you also provide the text.
Did you mean to cut out all context? Did you think that would provide a better answer?
I think there’s another thing that is important too which is otherwise unstated: the left hates the west. That’s why I included the western/nonwestern part at all, because I think it’s very possible that Doug and his wife also hate the west, though the only evidence I have for that is that he’s left aligned + didn’t make the distinction.
Your claude does bring up a good point: the fact these aren’t parallel categories. Claude seems fixated on historical stuff which makes the asymmetry important. But if there are no western countries interested in doing genocide recently, then I think the lefty interpretation is quite uncharitable towards me. I am saying that some nonwestern people think genocide is good and some nonwestern people think genocide is bad, so my framing explicitly includes the good people and separates them from the bad (good/bad within the genocide framing).