That is partially what I’m trying to figure out. I want to be a philosopher but I don’t know where to proceed from there.
I’ve always looked at a lot of stuff and thought about it a good bit and wrote down my thoughts on it. Currently I’m just sharing my thoughts on stuff after consuming it.
In relation to the “Capitalism Means Policing Big Companies” I’d like to share a couple things related to the Fraud section.
When it comes to policing big companies I think another issue is that our whole criminal justice system is run poorly. Not just that its corrupt.
I used to watch a lot of Last Week Tonight. Whenever John Oliver would talk about a lot of issues he’d always talk about how their were already laws on the books to address them. I think thats an important thing to consider. For a lot of bad stuff done by big companies their are already laws on the books to address them roughly. Its just our court system is bad. You can find information about how our court systems alone are overburdened. From Last Week Tonights public defender video, a bit before the two minute mark, public defenders in Fresno county handle 1000 felonies a year when they technically shouldn’t handle more than 150 a year. You can find lots of cases of people taking plea deals because they are more efficient. We’ve normalized trials to be extremely large arduous expenses instead of finding ways to make it more feasible (assuming that trials are even the correct solution).
Tying it back into Fraud: I think a lot of it simply doesn’t get addressed because we don’t have the manpower for it.
The second thing I’d like to share in relation to this is that I don’t think Fraud is considered an important issue to address for a lot of people. I remember commenting on an above reply about how redditors on r/antiwork weren’t talking about fraud.
The point being that what you care about matters. By this I mean that our criminal justice system does accomplish stuff (albeit poorly) when it cares about it. This is especially true in relation to drugs. Our whole justice system makes it a large priority when it comes to drug distribution and use.
Now this is where I’ll share something more anecdotal. I’ve heard of stories where people have gotten stolen from and the police show indifference. Ludwig, a twitch streamer, got his car stolen a year back and while the policy did eventually help I wonder if they would have helped him sooner and more efficiently if it was a drug related crime. What we care about matters. Though, should it?
The final thing I wanted to share here which is in alignment with the essay is that currently we have a lot of laws, a lot of bad laws. From Harvey Silverglate (an attorney), “But groups within civil society, not waiting for the federal bench, have launched an avowedly nonpartisan effort to rein in this species of prosecutorial abuse. In May 2010 an “odd couple” alliance of the conservative Heritage Foundation and the liberal National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) published “Without Intent,” a coauthored report detailing a major shortcoming of Congress’s drafting of criminal laws.34 The report found that of the 446 nonviolent, nondrug-related criminal laws presented in the 109th Congress, more than half lacked a requirement that a defendant act with criminal intent. Whether by design or by mere consequence, Congress has been making it easier for average citizens who did not intend to break the law to be convicted in federal criminal courts.” - Silverglate, Harvey A. ; Silverglate, Harvey. Three Felonies A Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent . Encounter Books. Kindle Edition. That’s just a small sliver of how many laws we have on the books for things I don’t think that matter that much. That’s another problem.
Our courts are overburdened, have bad priorities, and even if they didn’t have bad priorities they have so many laws on the books (most of which shouldn’t be laws) that they have to give importance to that they can’t reasonably be expected to focus on actual things that harm people.
*Sorry if its a bit messy and not well backed up. I’m just trying to share more and these are thoughts I’ve had for a while. I’ll probably make a post at some point with some better structuring.